Linwood Dyer Collection, Part 98
By Don Taylor • dontaylorgenealogy.com
Introduction
The Scarborough Historical Society maintains several important photographic collections documenting the people, places, and events of our community. In this installment of Faces from the Past, I examine a photo album from the Linwood Dyer Collection titled “Hinkley Family Photographs – Margaret Kinney.” Some photos have names written on the back; others include pink slips with identifying information. But many more, sadly, have no identifying information.
The first photo in the album bears an inscription to Marion Hinkley. Based on prior research into the Dyer Photo Collection, I established that Margaret Cogswell Kinney’s (1911–1995) mother was Eleanor Tisdale Hinkley, and Eleanor’s oldest sister was Marion Hinkley. The second photo carries the inscription “Grand Mother Prindle.” Marion Hinkley’s maternal grandparents were James and Eunice (Welch) Prindle — a connection that anchors the first two photos firmly to Marion’s branch of the family.
This installment focuses on five portraits spanning roughly eighty years of Hinkley and Prindle family history, from painted likenesses of the 1840s to a World War I military photograph.
James Lonson Prindle (1802–1851) — circa 1840
Inscription (front): To Marion Hinkly
Inscription (second hand): James Lonson Prindle

Description
This is a photograph of a painting rather than a direct photograph of the subject. The image depicts a man approximately 30 to 45 years of age. His dark coat, wide lapels, high-collared shirt, and cravat are characteristic of American men’s fashion from the 1820s through the 1850s. The three-quarter bust pose and plain background are typical of provincial portraiture of the era. The photograph itself was likely made in the late 19th or early 20th century for archival or family preservation purposes.
Research
James Lonson Prindle was the maternal grandfather of Marion Hinkley and the great-grandfather of Margaret Cogswell Kinney. Family Search records indicate he was born in Vermont in 1802. He married Eunice Welch and had at least four children: James, Edgar, E. L., and Frances. He died in 1851 in Whitehall, New York.
Dating the Image
The apparent age of the sitter — roughly 30 to 45 — suggests the original painting was executed between approximately 1832 and 1847. The clothing style and James’s death in 1851 are fully consistent with this range. A date in the early to mid 1840s, when James would have been in his late 30s to early 40s, seems most probable.
This photograph has been added to the Linwood Dyer Collection on Ancestry.com.
Eunice (Welch) Prindle (1810–1895) — circa 1840–1845 (Painted Portrait)
Inscription: Grand Mother Prindle
Photo placement: Same page as the portrait of James Lonson Prindle, consistent with a husband-and-wife pairing.

Description
This is a photograph of a painting, not a direct photograph of the subject. The image depicts a woman approximately 30 to 45 years of age. Her long ringlet curls worn at the sides of the face are a very distinctive hairstyle most fashionable during the 1840s and into the early 1850s. She wears a dark dress with a wide V-neckline trimmed with a lace collar, and a delicate chain necklace with a cross pendant is visible at the center of the chest. The photograph was likely made in the late 19th or early 20th century for family preservation.
Research
Eunice Welch (1810–1895) was the wife of James Lonson Prindle (1802–1851), the grandmother of Marion Hinkley (1868–1908), and the great-grandmother of Margaret Cogswell Kinney (1911–1995). A later photograph of Eunice in this same album (see below) allows a confident comparison across decades.
Dating the Image
The sitter’s apparent age, combined with the ringlet hairstyle and lace-trimmed neckline, is consistent with a painting date of approximately 1840 to 1845, when Eunice would have been in her early to mid thirties.
This photograph has been added to the Linwood Dyer Collection on Ancestry.com.
“Grandfather Hinkley” — circa 1850 (Identity Uncertain)
Inscription: Grand Father Hinkley

Description
This is a photograph of a painting rather than a direct photograph of the subject. The canvas texture and brushwork are clearly visible across the entire image, and a warm varnish yellowing typical of aged oil paintings gives the image its golden-brown cast. The sitter is a man approximately 50 to 65 years of age, with light brown to graying hair, somewhat wavy and receding at the temples. He is clean-shaven with a broad forehead and a composed, dignified expression. He wears a dark coat with wide lapels, a white high-collared shirt, and a black bow tie — consistent with American men’s fashion of the 1835–1860 period.
Research Note
If the album belonged to Marion Hinkley, then “Grandfather Hinkley” would most likely refer to Stephen Hinkley, Jr. (1799–1867). However, comparing this portrait with a previously reviewed photograph of Stephen Hinkley, Jr., I do not believe they depict the same individual. Stephen’s father, Stephen Hinkley, Sr. (1774–1804), can be ruled out: he died at approximately age 30, and the sitter in this portrait is clearly a much older man.
I intend to re-examine the photographs previously attributed to Stephen Hinkley, Jr. to confirm or revise that identification before drawing further conclusions about this portrait. The identity of “Grandfather Hinkley” remains an open question pending that review.
Eunice (Welch) Prindle (1810–1895) — circa 1871–1880 (Cabinet Card)
Photographer: Lamson, Portland, ME

Description
This is a direct photograph — a cabinet card or carte de visite — rather than a photograph of a painting. The image depicts a woman approximately 60 to 75 years of age. She has gray to white curly hair worn beneath a white widow’s cap, a style commonly adopted by older Victorian women. Her dark dress is accented with a white collar or fichu fastened at the throat with a small dark brooch. Her expression is serious and composed, with a direct gaze — consistent with the demeanor visible in the painted portrait made some thirty years earlier.
Though the album copy does not name the photographer, two loose cabinet cards elsewhere in the album bear the imprint “Lamson, Portland, ME.” Lamson’s studio did not add a street address to its cabinet cards until after 1880, which places these photographs between approximately 1871 and 1880. At that time Eunice would have been in her early to mid sixties.
Comparison with the Painted Portrait
Comparing this cabinet card with the earlier painted portrait of Eunice, several facial features are consistent across the two images: the long, narrow face; the prominent, straight brow; the firm set of the mouth; and the long neck. The approximately 30-year interval between the two images accounts for the dramatic changes in hair color and the visible aging of the face. A previous review of this same photograph appears in Linwood Dyer Collection, Part 084.
Philip Edward Hinkley (1881–1962) — circa 1919
Inscription: Philip Hinkley (on a separate slip of paper)

Description
This is a high-quality studio portrait — a gelatin silver print — taken against a professionally painted backdrop. The sitter is a lean, upright young man in his late 20s to mid 30s, clean-shaven, with short light brown hair neatly combed back. He wears a U.S. Army officer’s service coat with a stand collar, four chest pockets, and a single star insignia visible on the shoulder epaulette. The uniform cut and style are consistent with the American Expeditionary Forces dress of 1917–1919.
Research
Philip Edward Hinkley (1881–1962) served as a Major during World War I. He was the brother of Marion Hinkley and the uncle of Margaret Cogswell Kinney. A photograph of Philip was previously reviewed in Linwood Dyer Collection, Part 084; the present image appears to have been taken at a slightly different angle and distance but depicts the same individual.
Philip’s birth year of 1881 places him at approximately 37 to 38 years of age at the likely date of this photograph — consistent with the apparent age of the sitter.
This photograph has been added to the Linwood Dyer Collection on Ancestry.com.
Conclusion
This installment of Faces from the Past presents five portraits drawn from a single family album, spanning roughly eighty years of Hinkley and Prindle family history. The paired paintings of James Lonson Prindle and Eunice (Welch) Prindle offer a rare glimpse of a mid-19th century couple, while the later cabinet card of Eunice in old age provides a moving counterpart to her youthful portrait. The identity of “Grandfather Hinkley” remains to be confirmed through further research, and I welcome any information that might help resolve it.
If any of the individuals shown here are familiar to you, I would be very pleased to hear from you. Many photographs in the Scarborough Historical Society’s collections still lack personal identification, and even a small detail can help restore a name or a story. My continuing goal is to reconnect these images with the families and communities to whom they belong — ensuring they are preserved, understood, and shared for future generations.
Disclaimer: This article was researched and written by the author. Claude.ai was used as a research and drafting aid, and Grammarly was used for editorial review and copy editing.










