SHS Photo Collection – Part 11
By Don Taylor
In this installment of Faces from the Past, I examine five photographs from the Scarborough Historical Society Photo Collection. This installment presents five cabinet card portraits, dating from approximately 1876 to 1891. Three of the subjects have direct Scarborough connections — Charles Moulton, his wife Hannah Libby Meserve Moulton, both of Scarborough, and Rosile Dolley Poland of West Scarborough. The remaining two portraits — Dr. Willis Bean Moulton, grandson of Charles and Hannah, and an unidentified young man from Lewiston — round out this collection. Together, they offer a window into Maine life in the latter half of the nineteenth century, from prosperous Portland physicians to humble West Scarborough families navigating hard times.
Charles Moulton (1801-1891)

Charles Moulton was born in 1801, the eldest son of Captain Joshua Moulton (1775–1855) and Lydia Stone (1780–1872). Charles married Hannah Meserve (b. 1806), and together they raised a large family of eight children:
- John B. (b. between 1831-1832)*,
- Lydia M. (b. 1833),
- Esther J. (1835–1908),
- Mathias M. (1839–between 1903-1920)*,
- Olive (1842–1926),
- Charles (1844–1932),
- Liberty (1848–1923), and
- Fanny (b. 1851).
His son Mathias M. Moulton married Rose Ann Bean, and their son Willis Bean Moulton (1877–1934) married Jean S. Moulton. This cabinet card portrait, photographed by Conaut, was taken sometime between 1876 and 1891, capturing Charles in his later years. He lived to the remarkable age of 90, passing away in 1891.
Hannah Libby Meserve Moulton (1806–1884)

Hannah Libby Meserve was born on 13 December 1806 in Scarborough, Cumberland, Maine, the daughter of John Meserve (1767–1831) and Hannah Libby (1775–1859). On 21 November 1829, she married Charles Moulton (1801–1891), and together they raised eight children:
- John B. (b. between 1831-1832)*,
- Lydia M. (b. 1833),
- Esther J. (1835–1908),
- Mathias M. (1839–between 1903-1920)*,
- Olive (1842–1926),
- Charles (1844–1932),
- Liberty (1848–1923), and
- Fanny (b. 1851).
Census records show the family living in Gorham in 1850, returning to Scarborough by 1860, and back to Gorham by 1870. Hannah passed away on 17 January 1884 in Scarborough, Maine, and was buried in Portland, Cumberland County. Her husband Charles survived her by seven years, living until 1891. This cabinet card portrait, photographed by Conaut, appears to predate the portrait of her husband Charles, and is dated between 1876 and 1884 — suggesting it may have been taken while the couple were still living together in their later years, and no later than the year of Hannah’s death.
(Probably) Rosile Dolley Poland (1837–1890)

Rosile Dolley was born in 1837 and married Alvin J. Poland (1834–1914) as his second wife, Alvin having previously been married to Martha W. Pennell (1832–1864). By 1880 the couple were living in Biddeford, but by 1889 they had relocated to the West Scarborough area, near the Broad Turn School district (District No. 10). Town records reflect the family’s difficult circumstances in these final years — the 1889 Scarborough Town Report records Mrs. A. J. Poland receiving $2 in support, and Alvin receiving $14 for labor on the town farm buildings, while the 1890 Town Report notes Alvin receiving $10 worth of supplies as a recipient off the Poor Farm. Alvin filed for a Civil War pension on July 20, 1889, suggesting he was a veteran. Rosile passed away in 1890, after which Alvin is recorded as a widower living in Saco in the 1900 census. He lived until 1914. This cabinet card portrait, inscribed on the reverse “A. J. Poland, West Scarboro,” is believed to depict Rosile Dolley Poland, with the photo’s style and clothing suggesting a date of approximately 1887–1890, consistent with her final years in Scarborough.
Dr. Willis Bean Moulton (1877–1934)

Willis Bean Moulton was born on March 20, 1877, in Portland, Maine, the son of Mathias M. Moulton (1839–1903) and Rose Ann Bean, and the grandson of Charles Moulton (1801–1891) and Hannah Libby Meserve (1806–1884) of Scarborough, Maine. Educated in the Portland Public Schools, he graduated from Bowdoin College and Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Maryland, establishing himself as a surgeon and gynecologist in Portland, serving on the staffs of several Portland hospitals.
During World War I, he was commissioned as a captain in 1918, serving in the Medical Officers’ Training Group and later as acting commanding officer of Evacuation Hospital No. 57. He was discharged in August 1919 with the rank of major. A Fellow of the American College of Surgeons, he was also a member of the Portland Medical Society, the Cumberland County Medical Society, and the Maine Medical Association. He married Jean S. Moulton, who survived him. Dr. Willis Bean Moulton passed away on September 14, 1934, at the Maine Eye and Ear Infirmary from pneumonia. This cabinet card portrait was taken by photographer Webber of Brunswick, Maine.
Unidentified Man, Lewiston, Maine (c. 1890)

This cabinet card portrait was taken by Colpitts & Co., 52 Lisbon Street, Lewiston, Maine, circa 1890. The subject is a young man, approximately 20–30 years of age, seated on a decorative stone prop before a painted landscape backdrop, a typical studio arrangement of the era. He is well dressed in a dark sack coat suit with a waistcoat, visible watch chain, and striped cravat, and holds a bowler hat in his lap — suggesting a man of modest means dressed for a formal occasion. The name “Mary A. Smith” (or possibly “Margit Smith” is written on the reverse, almost certainly identifying the owner or recipient of the photograph rather than the subject himself. Mary A. Smith may have been a wife, sweetheart, sister, or friend of this unidentified young man. Unfortunately, there are several Mary Smiths in the Lewiston-Auburn area, and the identity of the subject remains unknown. Research assistance welcome.

Conclusion
These five cabinet card portraits represent both the rewards and the challenges of historical photo identification. Three have been identified with confidence, one tentatively, and one remains a complete mystery. If you have information that might help identify the young man photographed by Colpitts & Co. of Lewiston, or can shed further light on any of the other subjects, please contact me using the comments form below.
Endnotes:
* My quick research uncovered multiple dates for this individual’s birth, marriage, or death. Further research is necessary.
Disclaimer: This article was researched and written by the author. ChatGPT was used for photo improvement, Claude was used as a research and drafting aid, and Grammarly was used for editorial review and copy editing.







