Was Trickery Used Against Grandpa Brown?

Grandpa Brown In the News
88 Years Ago Today
By Don Taylor

Grandpa Brown found himself in the news again. He had abducted my mom from Illinois and brought her to Minnesota. He was then apparently removed from Minnesota illegally by Chicago officers.

From the Brainerd Daily Dispatch, April 9, 1935, Page 1.


Probe Whether Trickery Used by Chicago

Officer for Illegal Removal of Local Man

Image of article: From the Brainerd Daily Dispatch, April 9, 1935, Page 1.
Probe Whether Trickery Used by Chicago
Officer for Illegal Removal of Local Man

Brainerd Daily Dispatch, April 09, 1935 Pg. 1, Brainerd, Minnesota, US via Newspaper Archive

Voluntary return of Clifford Brown, local man apparently illegally removed from Minnesota by Chicago officers, will be asked of Gov. Henry Horner of Illinois by Gov. Floyd B. Olson if it develops force or trickery was used in gaining custody special advices to the Daily DISPATCH at 3 p.m. today day.

At 3 p. m. this afternoon, Officer Enright had not arrived in Chicago. The state’s attorney office there insisted that “if Enrgiht [sic] took Brown from Brainerd it must have been after Brown waived extradition,” the special advices to the daily DISPATCH said.

Chief of Police Thomas Templeton, queried late this afternoon by Gov. Floyd B. Olson as to whether or not trickery was used by the Chicago officer in effecting Brown’s release, wired this reply:

“Clifford Brown released to Chicago officers on your signature, Brown told them he desired to fight extradition but apparently they took him immediately.”

Reference to the governor’s signature was made to the warrant secured by Chicago officers containing a 24-hour period clause for consideration of a demand to fight extradidion. Brown was not permitted the 24 hour period.

—–

Clifford Brown, Brainerd, arrested here several days ago on an abduction charge filed by Chicago authorities apparently we being returned to Illinois without having been granted a proper extradition hearing, according to attaches of the governor’s office, The Daily Dispatch learned late today.

Brown was delivered into the custody of Harold Enright, Chicago officer, whi with Mrs. Donna Clark, the complaining witness, arrived here last night. Enright immediately started back, presumably for St. Paul for an extradition hearing.

Up to a late hour today, the Chicago officer and his prisoner had failed to put in an appearance at the Governor’s office, leading to the belief that Brown was being illegally removed to Illinois.

It was pointed out, advices from St. Paul said, that Brown should have been given 24 hours to notify authorities that he wished an extradition hearing. The 24-hour period would not elapse until 9 p. m. tonight, the extradition clerk in St. Paul said.

Meanwhile, W. J. Swanson, counsel for Brown here, had notified State Attorney Courtney in Chicago and also the governor’s office that Brown would demand an extradition hearing. Swanson received a wire from State

S Attorney Courtney yesterday saying Enright and Mrs. Clark were enroute to Brainerd. Swanson expected that Enright would contact him upon his arrival but he was not informed until today that Brown had been delivered into Brainer authorities indicated that the custody of the Chicago officer. Brown had not changed his mind about fighting extradition when he was given in the hands of the Chicago officers as he reiterated at that time his rightful demand for an extradition hearing.

Failure of Officer Enright to present his charge before the extradition clerk, failure to permit him to consult his counsel, the belief that Brown refused to waive extradition and the apparent removal of Brown from the state indicated his illegal extradition.

Local authorities considered it impossible to contact Enright in view of the fact that they were traveling by auto.

The 3-year old child whom Brown is charged with abducting was given over by county authorities to Mrs. Donna Clark, who swore out the warrant for Brown’s arrest. Brown admits he is the father of the child but said that he and Mrs. Clark, said to be the mother, were unmarried.

The child had been in the care of Brown’s mother, Mrs. Mary Brown here, pending arrival of the Chicago authorities.

Mrs. Clark was expected to return to Chicago with the Child late today or tomorrow.

Posted in 88 Years Ago, Brown, In the news | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Grandpa Brown Fights Extradition.

Grandpa Brown In the News

88 Years Ago Today
By Don Taylor

Grandpa Brown abducted mom and was in custody at Brainerd, awaiting extradition.

From the Brainerd Daily Dispatch, April 8, 1935, Page 1.


CAPTION

To Fight Extradition on
Charge of Child Abduction.

Claiming that he has as much right to the custody of the three year old child is charged with abducting as Mrs. Donna Clark, Chicago entertainer and complainant, Clifford Brown today noticed announced through his council W.J. Swanson that he would fight extradition.

Brown, in jail here, admitted that he and Mrs. Clark were unmarried by claimed that he is the father of the child. Reports from St. Paul said that extradition papers were being secured there and would be sent to Brainerd at once.


St. Paul—An extradition request from Illinois authorities for Clifford Brown, in custody at Brainerd, was received at the governor’s office today.

Papers for Brown’s return to Illinois will be mailed to Brainerd this afternoon, attaches at the governor’s office said. They will be sent to the county attorney, who will oppose Brown’s expected attempt to prevent removal.

Brown was arrested at Brainerd on a charge of abducting his three year old daughter, Sylvia. The girl brown said, is the daughter of Mrs. Donna Clark, Chicago night club entertainer. Brown said he and Mrs. Clark are not married.

Posted in 88 Years Ago, Brown, In the news | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Photo Friday – Rich, Rideout & Riley

File: Ethel Wight Collection – Part 125
By Don Taylor

Photo of Don Taylor with cat Nasi.

This week, for Photo Friday, I identify the people in five more envelopes from the Ethel Wight Studio Collection[i]. The envelopes typically contain the name of the person who paid for the photos, not necessarily of the individual portrayed in the image. As such, it is vital to analyze the pictures and information to identify the individual therein.[ii] Ultimately, my goal is to reunite the photos with family members who may have never seen the image.


Nurse Edith Rich, circa 1935.

The envelope this negative was in says, “Miss Edith Rich, State St. Hospital #952.” This photo appears to be of a woman in her late teens or early 20s in a nurse’s uniform.

Photo of Nurse Edith Rich, circa 1935.
Nurse Edith Rich, circa 1935.

Why I believe this to be the individual.

  • The 1938 Portland City Directory indicates that Edith Rich was a nurse who moved to Sebago Lake.
  • The 1940 US Census listed Edith E Rich, a nurse who lived in Portland in 1935 and Standish in 1940.[iii] (Note: She is 26 years old and was born in Maine.
  • The 1930 US Census lists Edith E Rich, the 16-year-old daughter of Layman Rich, living in Standish, Maine.

Alternate Individuals.

Do not confuse her with Edith A Rich, who lived at 184 High St in Portland in 1938.

Conclusion

I am sure this photo is of Edith Esther Rich, the daughter of Layman Henry and Alice (Prescott) Rich. Ancestry has three public trees that refer to Edith Esther Rich. Family Search has profile G9KH-X4F for Edith Esther Rich. I have uploaded two photos of Edith to her Family Search Memories.


Nurse Marcella Riley, circa 1936.

This negative envelope says, “Miss Marcella Riley, St. Barnabas Hospital #1016.” This photo appears to be of a woman in her late teens or early 20s in a nurse’s uniform.

Photo of Nurse Marcella Riley, circa 1936.
Nurse Marcella Riley, circa 1936.

Why I believe this to be the individual.

  • The 1937 Portland City Directory lists Marcella Riley as a student nurse at 231 Woodford (St. Barnabas Hospital).
  • The Bangor Daily News, dated 19 March 1939, reported that Marcella K Riley, daughter of Mrs. Elizabeth Gillespie, would marry James J. Lee. She was a graduate of St. Barnabas Hospital and a nurse. The photo of Marcella in the paper is clearly of the same young woman.

This photo appears to be of Nurse Marcella K Riley circa 1936.

Ancestry has six public trees that refer to Marcella K. Riley, born 16 Jan 1916 in New Brunswick, Canada, and who married James Joseph Lee on 3 Jul 1939. Family Search does not appear to have a profile for Marcella Riley, so I uploaded a photo of Marcella to Dead Fred.


photo of a man in his 50s, possibly Ira Rindsay, circa 1936.
Possibly Ira Rindsay, circa 1936.

“Ira Rindsay?”

This negative envelope says, “Mr. Ira Rindsay, Mar 1936, #1142B.” This photo appears to be of a man in his 40s or 50s.

What I discovered.

  • A search of Ancestry did not find anyone with the name Ira Rindsay.
  • A Google Search for Ira Rindsay failed to find any results.
Photo of envelopy showing Ira Rindsay
Photo of envelope showing “Mr. Ira Rindsay – Mar-1936

Although the envelope clearly indicates Ira Rindsay, I cannot identify the person in the photo and suspect the envelope is incorrect. I only include the individual’s picture here and have not posted it elsewhere.


Reid Rideout, circa 1935 (age 1).

This negative envelope says, “Mrs. Clayton Rideout, 57 Bradley #833. ”

Photo of Reid Rideout, circa 1935 (age 1).
Reid Rideout, circa 1935 (age 1).

Why I believe this to be the individual.

  • The 1935 Portland City Directory lists Clayton L Rideout and his wife, Vera G Rideout, living at 57 Bradley.
  • The 1940 US Census lists Layton and Vera Rideaut living at 57 Bradley with their two sons, Reid (age 5) and Paul (age 1).

This photo, taken about 1935, must be of Reid Rideout when he was 1-2 years old.

I have not found Reid in Ancestry trees; however, I have found his father, Clayton Lewis Rideout, in 39 public trees. Also, Family Search does not have a profile for Reid, so I uploaded a photo of Reid to Dead Fred.


FNU[iv] Revers child, circa 1935.

This negative envelope says, “Mrs. F. M. Revers ℅ H K Pray, 67 Bell St. #729.” This photo was taken about 1935 and appears to be of a young child, about two years old.

Photo of a young child, about 2 years old, circa 1935.
Unknown child, about 2 years old, circa 1935.

What I did do to try to determine this individual.

  • The 1935 Portland City Directory does not show an H. K. Pray. Walter A Scott is listed as living at 67 Bell in 1935 and 1936.
  • The 1941 Portland City Directory lists Lemuel E Pray residing at 67 Bell St.
  • A review of several Ancestry Trees containing Lemuel E Pray failed to find anyone with the surname of Revers that was related.
  • A review of the 1930 Census failed to discover any Prays with the initials H. K.

I have not discovered any identifying information regarding the child in this photo. I only include the individual’s image here.


Conclusion

  • I identified three of the five individuals in this photo negative set. Only one has a Family Search profile, so I uploaded that image to their Family Search Memories. Two did not have Family Search profiles, so I uploaded their photos to Dead Fred. The other two photo sets were unidentified, so their images only remain here.

I will love to hear your reaction if any of these photos are of your family member. Especially if this photo is of a loved one for whom you hadn’t seen this photograph before.

Due to software limitations, the images uploaded to Family Search, Dead Fred, and Flickr have higher quality than those linked here.

For all postings of the Ethel Wight Collection, please see here.


Endnotes

[i] The Wight Studio was in Portland, Maine. Many thanks to Ethel Wight’s family for access to and permission to use the collection of their great aunt.
[ii] These images were converted to positives using a lightbox, a Nikon camera and computer software.
[iii] Standish includes the southern shore of Sebago Lake.
[iv] FNU – First Name Unknown.

Posted in Ethel Wight Studio, Photo Friday | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Grandpa Brown Charged with Abduction

Grandpa Brown In the News

88 Years Ago Today
By Don Taylor

Grandpa Brown found himself again. He had abducted mom and was being held for the Chicago Police.

From the Brainerd Daily Dispatch, April 6, 1935, Page 1.

Brainerd Man Held Here for Chicago
Officers Charged With Abduction

Clifford Brown, Brainerd, held in the city jail here for Chicago authorities who hold a warrant charging him with abduction of a 3-year-old girl today intimated to police that he would fight extradition.

Brown was taken into custody Thursday upon telegraphic orders from state attorney Thomas Courtney’s office in Chicago.

Brown appeared here about three weeks ago with Sylvia and immediately reported to police that he “expected trouble” out of Chicago. He told authorities he was the girl’s father, and relate that relate under what circumstances he had taken her from her mother. Mrs. Donna Clark, Chicago, nightclub entertainer.

Thursday when Brown was arrested, he again said he was Sylvia’s father, authorities said, but admitted that he was not married to Mrs. Clark.

—–

Chicago—State’s Attorney Thomas J. Courtney said today that extradition papers are being prepared to return Clifford Brown, held in jail at Brainerd, Minn, on charges of abducting a three year old girl.

Brown was arrested on complaint of the child’s mother, Mrs. Donna Clark of Chicago.

She charged that Brown, a former friend, came to her home March 10th and asked to take the child, Sylvia, for a walk. They failed to return and the following day she received a postcard from Brown explaining that they were aboard a bus for Brainerd, she said.

Mrs. Clark said the abduction was “spite work” and that Brown took the child to the home of his mother Mrs. Mary Brown in Brainerd. Mrs. Clark has another child older than Sylvia.

The mother, an entertainer, said she won a bathing beauty contest at Madison Square Garden in New York in 1916. She identified Brown as a former entertainer in nightclubs, now jobless.

Police said the problem of getting the baby back to her mother has remained unsettled when welfare agencies of both Chicago and Minnesota disclaimed the financial responsibility.

Brown, charged by the child mother, Mrs. Donna Clark, a night club entertainer, with taking the child because she refused to marry him, will not ??acy transportation back to Chicago, officials said. Extradition proceedings to return him have been started.

Authorities here said they knew nothing about providing railroad fare back to Chicago for the child.

“The state’s attorney’s office is concerned only with bringing Brown back.” James V. Cunningham, assistant state’s attorney said, “Payment of the girl’s fare is up to the welfare bureau here or to Minnesota authorities—I don’t know which.”

Mrs. Clark said Brown, whom she said had been attempting to persuade her to marry him for several months, disappeared with Sylvia March 10.

Posted in 88 Years Ago, Brown, In the news | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Grandpa Brown in Jail on Abduction

Grandpa Brown In the News

88 Years Ago Today
By Don Taylor

Grandpa Brown found himself again. This time based upon a telegram from the Illinois State Attorney. He knew there was going to be trouble, but….

From the Brainerd Daily Dispatch, April 5, 1935, Page 2.

MAN TAKEN HERE
FOR CHICAGO ON
ABDUCTION CHARGE

Brainerd Daily Dispatch – April 5, 1935, Page 2 via NewspaperArchive.

Clifford Brown, of Brainerd, today was in the city jail being held upon telegraphic orders from Assistant State’s Attorney Courtney’s office in Chicago.

According to the telegram received by local authorities, Brown is wanted on a charge of abduction. He indicated to Brainerd police that he would fight extradition.

Warrant for his custody was expected to arrive late today or tomorrow.

Brown, in a statement made to Brainerd police several weeks ago when he returned to this city, told them that he expected “some trouble from Chicago.”

Posted in 88 Years Ago, Brown, In the news | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment