We know that Donna had a show advertised as “Donna Darling and Earle in a Song and Dance Romance” in 1924. The Standiford Studio in Louisville, Kentucky took this photo entitled, “Donna Darling and Earle.”
Donna Darling & Murray Earle c. 1924
Donna and Earl played in Oakland California in June 1924, and at the Melba Theatre in Dallas, TX in July 1924. Seemingly like an easterly movement, I extrapolate they could have been in Louisville in August 1924. Of course, I could be entirely wrong. As a matter of fact, I would expect a photo like this to be taken towards the beginning of a tour rather than the end. In either event, the photograph is likely taken in 1924.
Follow-up
Continue research and find dates when Donna and Earle played in Louisville, KY.
It is usually the birth record, and how comfortable I am with that record, that defines how comfortable I am with my feeling that I know an ancestor. Nelson Barnes’ birth records, parents, and childhood records do not give me a warm fuzzy feeling. I have no sense of the cat purring behind my ear. But, here is what I think I know.
Roberts-Brown 2017 – Ancestor #20
List of Grandparents
Grand Parent: Essie Pansy Barnes
1st Great: Joel Clinton Barnes
2nd Great: Nelson Barnes
3rd Great: (Possibly Joel Barnes)
Nelson Barnes (1816-1884)
Birth
Thomas Wolfe, in A History of Sullivan County, Indiana,[i] indicates that Nelson Barnes was born in New York on 24 March 1816. It is very clear; however, Nelson Barnes’ Find a Grave Memorial [ii] indicates he was born on 6 December 1816. The photo on the memorial is too pixelated to be able to determine what it might say. So, I have submitted a Find-a-Grave photo request to try to get a higher quality image to look at.
Source ages and places of birth for Nelson Barnes
Document
Age
Supports Birth in
1850 Census
35 – Pennsylvania
December 1816
1860 Census
44 – New York
March 1816
1870 Census
54 – New York
March 1816
1880 Census
64 – New York
March 1816
1884 Find-a-Grave
If age 68 in January 1884, then
December 1816
1884 Find-a-Grave
New York
6 December 1816
1909 (Wolf book)
New York
24 March 1816
Marker for Mercy Eliza Taft Barnes and Nelson Barns. Photo by Wabash Valley Genealogy Society Cemetery Committee via Find a Grave
Normally, I like to use the document closest to the event. However, in this case, three of the four census records and the Wolf book indicate a different birth date makes me uncomfortable accepting the December 1816 birthdate. I’ve decided to ignore the Pennsylvania birthplace states in the 1850 Census as just wrong. His marker might indicate his age at death as 68 years and 29 days. If so, that would put his birth in December 1816 also. So, I’ve requested an updated find-a-grave image of his marker. Hopefully, the bottom line will be more readable. An improved image might clear his birth month up for me.
Childhood
I have not found any documents, so far, that clearly identify Nelson Barnes’ parents. That said, there are 11 family trees on Ancestry that share Nelson Barnes as an ancestor. All 11 of those trees indicate that Nelson Barnes’ parents were Joel and Lucy Wilson (Taft) Barnes. None of these researchers appear to have identified any siblings for Nelson nor have are any siblings identified on the Family Search family tree (ID: M1PY-5V8). Finally, the idea that Nelson married a Taft and that his father also married a Taft makes me uncomfortable. Are the identities confused by the researchers or did it really happen this way? Having Nelson’s father named Joel would explain one of his sons being named Joel. In the future, I will research Joel Barnes (the elder) and see if I can connect him to Nelson, but in the meantime, the relationship of Nelson to Joel and Lucy is very tentative.
Marriage
Nelson Barnes and Mercy Eliza Taft were united in marriage in New York on October 21, 1839.[iii]
Adulthood
Their first child, a daughter, has one of the most unusual names I’ve encountered – Tryphenia. Tryphenia (or Tryphena) was born in in 1841 in New York. Records seem to conflict about if she was born in Broome County (Binghamton area) or King’s County (Manhattan).
Likewise, their second child, also a daughter – was born in 1844, also in New York.
The family then located to Sullivan County, Indiana where Nelson and Mercy had seven more children, all in Sullivan County. They were:
Theodore 1847
Susan 1849
Abraham 1852
Cyrus 1855
Joel 1857
Lucy 1860
Martha 1863
Nelson was a farmer and attended Methodist Episcopal church. The 1850, 1860, 1870, and 1880 census records all clearly show him living in Sullivan County. Although some researchers indicate that Nelson served in the Civil War, I do not agree and believe the 45-year-old father of 8 remained out of the war. See “Nelson Barnes – Civil War Veteran?” for details.
Stories
In February 1879, Nelson and Mercy’s son Cyrus died at the age of 24.
Death & Burial
Nelson died on 21 January 1884 and is buried in Drake Cemetery, Fairbanks, Sullivan County, Indiana.[iv]
Further Actions / Follow-up
Research potential ancestors, Joel and Lucy Wilson (Taft) Barnes, and see if there is a descendant path to Nelson Barnes.
Endnotes and Sources
[i] Citation: Wolfe, Thomas J. 1909. A history of Sullivan County, Indiana, closing of the first century’s history of the county, and showing the growth of its people, institutions, industries and wealth. New York: The Lewis Pub. Co. Page 235.
As I researched Nelson Barnes I realized that many people are ascribing many Civil War records to Nelson indicating his service. Ancestry hints were indicating many different potential records that were all being ascribed to Nelson by various other researchers. I needed a way to help differentiate my Nelson from other Nelsons.
Sullivan County, Indiana
My Nelson Barnes was born in New York in 1816. According to Thomas Wolfe, Nelson and his wife located to Sullivan County, Indiana in the 1840s.[i] He was in Turman, Sullivan County, Indiana for the 1850, 1860, 1870, and 1880 censuses. Turman township is on the Indiana-Illinois boarder so it is possible that he enlisted in Illinois. Kentucky is about 100 miles away and there are many other places he could have enlisted if the 47 year-old, father of 8 desired to do so.
Looking at the 1860 Census, I eliminated any Nelson Barnes that was born before 1800 as being too old to serve in the Civil War. I also eliminated anyone born after 1850 as being too young to serve. That left 19 individuals including my Nelson Barnes reported in the 1860 Census.
1860 Census – Birth and residence for individuals named “Nelson Barnes.”
#
Birth
Birth Place
Residence in 1860
NB01
1809
Connecticut
Roxbury, CT
NB02
1812
Rhode Island
Johnston, RI
NB03
1814
New York
Jasper, NY
NB04
1815
Kentucky
Madison Co., KY
NB05
1815
New York
Vienna, IL
NB06
1816
New York
Turman, IN
NB07
1818
New York
Franklin, NY
NB08
1818
England
Hamilton, NJ
NB09
1826
New York
Afton, NY
NB10
1831
New York
Medina, MI
NB11
1832
New Hampshire
Boscawen, NH
NB12
1832
New York
Quincy, MI
NB13
1835
Connecticut
Litchfield, CT
NB14
1835
Vermont
Chicago, IL
NB15
1839
New York
Sennett, NY
NB16
1839
Rhode Island
Smithfield, RI
NB17
1839
Indiana
Washington, IN
NB18
1840
New York
Brutus, NY
NB19
1840
Illinois
Richland, IL
With a list of potential Nelson Barnes’ who could have potentially served in the Civil War, I need to look at each Nelson Barnes record and see if they fit my Nelson, another Nelson, or are not determinable from the record.
Randolph County, Indiana
There was a Nelson Barnes who served with the 8th Regiment, Indiana Infantry (3 months, 1861). This unit organized on 21 April 1861. The unit mustered in on 25 April, 1861 and mustered out on August 2, 1861. This fits the service of the Nelson Barnes who was from Randolph County who enlisted on 24 April 1861.
There was a Nelson Barnes who served with the 5th Regiment, Indiana Cavalry (90th Regiment, Indiana Volunteers). This regiment mustered in during August, September, and October of 1862. This fits the Nelson Barnes from Lynn, Indiana who enlisted on 13 Aug 1862. Lynn is a town in Randolph county close to the Ohio border.
All of the other civil war records that I am finding for “Nelson Barnes” appear to relate to one of the many other Nelson Barnes’s identified in the table above or the Nelson Barnes from Lynn, Randolph County, Indiana.
Additionally, the 1870 Census shows a Nelson Barnes living in Washington, Randolph County, Indiana. Meanwhile, our Nelson Barnes was living in Turman Township, Sullivan County, Indiana.
Finally, Lynn is a town in Washington Township in Randolph County. I have no doubt that all of the Nelson Barnes records in Indiana relate to that Nelson (NB17 above).
I don’t believe that Nelson Barnes who lived near Graysville in Turman Township, Sullivan County, Indiana served in the Civil War.
ENDNOTES & SOURCES
[i] Wolfe, Thomas J., History of Sullivan County, Indiana, A, Files (Personal), Page 235. A history of Sullivan County, Indiana, closing of the first century’s history of the county, and showing the growth of its people, institutions, industries and wealth. New York: The Lewis Pub. Co.
The first newspaper clipping in the collection is one that screams in big print, “DONNA MONTRAN.”
Scanned image from the Donna Darling Collection. Originally: From August 20, 1920, edition of “Variety,” New York City, page 40 (back cover) via the Donna Darling Collection.
It then speaks of her as “BROADWAY’S NEWEST FIND – Under Personal Direction of Tom Rooney.” The advertising also acknowledges her vocal instructor, Louis Howard Croxson, and her dancing master Alexis Kosloff. The clipping also shows that she is playing at B. S. Moss’ Broadway Theatre. Knowing that made it easier to find the paper and issue that the item ran in. (Emphasis mine.)
The clipping is a paid advertisement she took out promoting herself. I was able to find it in “Variety” newspaper, dated August 20, 1920, it was a half-page ad on the back cover of the trade newspaper. The ad also includes a collection of quotes about Donna that we will see many more times.
The Quotes:
VARIETY, July 30
“Donna Montran ha an undeniable million dollar smile, oodles of personality and an elastic voice that hits the high registers smoothly and effectively—wood make ideal $4 musical comedy stuff.”
Abel
“MORNING TELEGRAPH”
“Donna Montran is here. Take leading part well in beach promenade.”
“EVE. WORLD”
“Donna Montran was the bathing girl prima donna and had as pleasing a voice as any girl should need.”
“N. Y. CLIPPER”
“The music was tuneful and the song, “India, My Own,’ with words and music written by Donna Montran, was sung by the author with good effect. Miss Montran is pretty, possessed of a fine figure and has a smile and personality that count.”
“EVE. MAIL” (July 26)
“There is the pretty, dainty Donna Montran, whose swimming hasn’t destroyed her voice.”
“EVE. SUN”
“Donna Montran. A blo/??
young lady who contributes /??
explanatory singing, manage /???
part well and exhibited some /????
pretty costumes.”[i]
The People
Thomas Rooney
Donna married Thomas Rooney on November 24, 1915, in Waltham, MA. So, it is clear that she and Tom were together for quite a few years. I am a little surprised that the very independent Donna would go for the phrase, “Under Personal Direction of Tom Rooney.” (I definitely need to do more research about him.)
Lewis Howard Croxson
Louis Howard Croxson was a vocal teacher who had a studio in the Metropolitan Opera House building. Apparently, he was well known in New York stage circles. Among those he had instructed were Miss Tossa Kosta of “The Chocolate Soldier,” Miss Dorothy South of the “Wild Cat,” Miss Patricia Ryan, Carl Hayden, the Australian concert singer, Misses Irene Castle, Josie Colline and Bertha Shalek, his sister in law.[ii] Through this ad we learn he also instructed vaudeville star, Donna Montran.[iii]
Alexis Kosloff
Alexis Kosloff c. 1917
Alexis Kosloff taught Russian Ballot and was very well known in New York. He danced in the imperial Russian Ballet before coming to America and was a writer, choreographer, and dance instructor. His book, Russian ballet technique, as taught by Alexis Kosloff: Method of practising foundation steps, potpourri of exercises, suite of dances, with descriptions and music, is a classic. He taught Donna how to dance. No wonder reviews of her shows often praised her dance ability. She was trained by the best and she gave him credit in this advertisement.
Conclusion
Clearly, it was important for Donna to promote herself. During a time when women were typically demure, she stood up and promoted herself. Showing herself as being personally managed by Tom Rooney, taught voice by Louis Howard Croxson, and taught Dance by Alexis Kosloff was her way of saying she was the “real deal.” Advertising in “Variety” was a way to gain prestige exposure with theater agents and others who could book her act.
Follow-up / Future Research
Thomas Valentine Rooney, Donna’s 2nd husband.
Endnotes & Sources
[i] The Donna Montran Collection news-clipping is torn and the last words on each line of this quote are missing. Unfortunately, the Archives.Org image of that paper also is cut off on the right causing the words on the right to be missing.
Thanks to autosomal DNA testing, I’ve learned who my biological father is. I have discovered and met some of my “new” half-siblings on my biological father’s side. I have also discovered that my wife has a previously unknown half-sister. Now, due to DNA testing, I’ve found that my mother has a previously unknown half-sister.
It began with an email from (I’ll call her) HC, who indicated that Ancestry DNA was saying that she and I were first or second cousins. The Ancestry match reported that she and I share 460cM of material. A look at our trees showed no surnames in common. Ancestry allows you to view a match and see who also shares that match. My half-sister, Glennis, was also a match and shares, even more, DNA (522 centimorgans) than I share with HC. That proves that the match was on my maternal side as Glennis and I share a common mother.
HC & I share 460cM
Through an exchange of messages, I learned that HC’s mother was adopted, was born in May of 1938 in Texas, however, her mother was conceived in Minnesota. That narrowed things considerably. My mom’s Montran/Barber line pretty much was from Michigan; my mom’s Brown/Manning line was from Minnesota. So, it was very likely that the match came from my mother’s father’s side of the family. Luckily, my mother has a half-sister. The bad news is that neither my mother or her half-sister, Barbara, tested with Ancestry.
No problem, GEDMatch to the rescue. Although both tested with another service, I had previously exported their data from the other system and imported the data into GEDMatch. If HC was a match with my mother and aunt Barbara, then the common ancestor had to be on their common father’s side. If the match was only with my mother and not my aunt Barbara, then the common ancestor had to be on her Montran side. I know very little about Montran line, so anything could be possible.
HC uploaded her data to GEDMatch and the results were amazing. She shares over 1000 centimorgans of DNA with BOTH my mother and my aunt Barbara – Proof that the common line is on the Brown side. I like to use The DNA Geek’s chart to quickly see the potential relationships between individuals at a particular centimorgans level. The chart shows that 1000 cM is solidly in the range of Group C relatives. Relationships for Group C include First Cousin, Half Aunt-Uncle/Niece-Nephew, Great-Grand Parent/Child and Great Aunt-Uncle/Niece-Nephew.
Now that I know that the match is on the Brown line I can speculate.
Grandpa Dick
If Grandpa Dick is the father of HC’s mother, then HC would be the half-niece of my mother and Aunt Barbara. That fits the amount of DNA Perfectly.
If one of Grandpa Dick’s brothers were the father of HC’s mother then, HC and my mother would be first cousins once removed and I would expect a DNA match of between 215 and 650.
Dick’s father died in 1928, so he can’t possibly be the father of HC’s mother, so that scenario isn’t possible.
Finally, I questioned was there is a locational opportunity for Grandpa Dick to be the father. HC’s mother was conceived while her mother was in Deerwood, MN about August of 1938. In 1937, my Grandpa Dick was living in Brainerd, Minnesota, about 18 miles from Deerwood.
I think that is enough to prove the relationship. However, I always like to go the extra mile if possible and prove it beyond the shadow of a doubt. HC’s mother is still alive and recently had her DNA tested. When the results come back, we can confirm this relationship. I expect that the autosomal DNA match with my mother and with Aunt Barbara will be in the 2000cM range – solidly in the half-sibling range.
Additional proof will come through a comparison of the X chromosome. Females have two X-chromosomes (males have an X and a Y). One of the X chromosomes is from the mother and is recombinant, that is to say, it is a mix of the mother’s X. The other X chromosome is a replica of the father’s X and is passed on without change. If HC’s mother and my mother are half-siblings, I would expect to see their X-Chromosome to have a solid match like my mother and her half-sister Barbara have.
X Chromosome match of my mom & Aunt Barbara.
My mother and my Aunt Barbara have a here-to-for completely unknown half-sister. Amazing. I always heard that Grandpa Dick “liked the ladies.” I guess he did. I now know of four daughters that he fathered, my mom, Aunt Barbara, Aunt Mary Lou, and newly found Aunt Phyllis. I wonder if there are more….
Note:
I do not typically use the full name of living individuals.
Of course, if any DNA specialists see anything incorrect with my reasoning above, please let me know via the contact form below.