Howell Research Howell-Pankey Line
Census Sunday
By Don Taylor
Following families in the early census records is always tricky. Today, I am looking at the 1810 Census and Thomas (and Martha) Pankey of Cumberland County, Virginia.
From my other research, I believe the Thomas Armstrong Pankey household of 1810 should consist of the following:
Free White Persons – Males – Under 10: 2 Francis & Thomas
Free White Persons – Males – 16 thru 25: 1 FNU
Free White Persons – Males – 45 and over: 1 Thomas
Free White Persons – Females – Under 10: 3 Elizabeth
Possibly Henrietta and a new FNU
Free White Persons – Females – 16 thru 25: 2 Nancy & Mary
Free White Persons – Females – 45 and over: 1 Martha
It would appear that the 22-year-old female had married and was gone from the household.
It would also appear that the FNU girl under 10 is a heretofore unknown girl or is the same girl that I thought might be 22 years old, and I have her age entirely wrong.
Earlier Censuses
The 1790 Population Schedule for Virginia is lost.[ii]
The 1800 Population Schedule only includes Accomack and Louisa counties.[iii]
Conclusion
I believe this Census reflects the Thomas Armstrong House of Cumberland County, Virginia, in 1810.
This week, for Photo Friday, I identify the people in five more envelopes from the Ethel Wight Studio Collection[i]. The envelopes contain the names who paid for the photos, not necessarily of the individual portrayed in the image. As such, it is vital to analyze the pictures and information to identify the individual therein.[ii] Ultimately, my goal is to reunite the photos with family members who may have never seen the image.
Harold and Richard McCann (brothers), Circa 1934.
The envelope this negative was in says, “H. W. McCann, Loring Short & Harmon, #140 .”
Why I believe this to be the individual.
Harold and Richard McCann (brothers), Circa 1934.
The 1935 Portland City Directory lists Harold W and his wife Hazel McCann living at 103 Clinton. Harold was a credit manager at 474 Congress. Loring Short & Harmon was a bookseller and stationer at 474 Congress.
The 1936 Deering High School (Portland, ME) yearbook shows Harold W McCann’s photo. It is clearly the same young man as in this photograph.
The 1940 Census lists Harold W. & Hazel McCann living at 113 Glenwood. Living with them are Harold Jr., age 21, and Richard, age 19.
This photo, taken about 1934, includes Harold W McCann, Jr., and his brother Richard when the boys were about 15 and 13 years old.
Ancestry has 22 public trees that refer to Harold Webster McCann, born 17 Dec 1918. Family Search has a profile L6JX-PRP for Harold Webster McCann Jr (1918-2013). I have uploaded two photos of him and his brother to their Family Search Memories.
The 1935 Portland City Directory lists Evelyn MacNeill as a student nurse at 79 Bramhall. (The Maine Eye and Ear Infirmary was located at 79 Bramhall.)
The Ancestry copy of the 1936 Portland City Directory is missing the pages that would have MacNeill entries.
The 1937 Portland City Directory does not have Evelyn MacNeil listed.
The 1933 Deering High School Yearbook lists Evelyn L MacNeil as a Senior. Her photo in the yearbook could be of the same young woman.
Alternative Individuals
The 1930 US Census lists Evelyn L MacNeill as the 14-year-old daughter of Ethel M. MacNeill, living in Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts.
The 1930 Census also lists 11-year-old Evelyn L MacNeill, the daughter of Clyde and
Wilhemina MacNeill, living in Oak Bluffs, Dukes County, Massachusetts.
I am confident this is Evelyn L. MacNeil/MacNeill, a student nurse at the Maine Eye and Ear Infirmary in 1935. She also likely attended Deering High School in 1933. However, I have been unable to connect Evelyn, the nurse, to her parents or a spouse.
This negative envelope says, “Miss Sue McCauley, Children’s Hospital #655.”
Why I couldn’t find this individual.
1934, 1935, and 1936 Portland City Directories list no “McCauley” (or similar name) in the Nurses section.
Likely match
Susan MacAulay (Nurse) Circa 1935.
The 1940 US Census lists a Susan MacAulay (or Macauley) as a 35-year-old Canadian-born nurse living and working in Westport, Fairfield County, Connecticut. In 1935 she resided in Bridgeport, Fairfield County, Connecticut. The 1930 US Census confirms her occupation as a Nurse.
In this photo, the nurse appears to be about 30 years old, which fits Nurse Susan MacAulay of Connecticut. So, I believe it may be her, but I am not certain about the identification.
I have added a photo of Susan MacAulay to Dead Fred. I also uploaded an additional image of Sue to my Flickr photostream.
Daughter of Harry A & Margaret MacDonough, Circa 1935.
This negative envelope says, Mrs. H. A. MacDonough, 548 Stevens Ave #435 – DSCN4016P.”
Why I believe this to be the individual.
Daughter of Harry A & Margaret MacDonough, Circa 1935.
The 1935 Portland City Directory lists Harry A (Margaret M) MacDonough as a salesman living at 548 Stevens.
The 1929 Portland City Directory lists Harry A and Margaret B Macdonough living at 21 Rackleff.
The 1931 Portland City Directory lists Harry A and Margaret M Macdonough living at 21 Rackleff
The 1930 Portland City Directory indicates that Harry and Margaret’s neighbors at 21 Rackleff included:
Howard L Churchill, William T Sawyer, Mrs. Marion M Hunt, and Arthur C Frost.
Looking at Marion Hunt, I found Harry Mc Doughan, age 40, born in Maine, and his wife Margaret, age 32, born in Maine, living at 21 Rackleff. They had been married for two years.
The 1938 Portland City Directory found Harry & Margaret Macdonough living at 30 State.
The 1940 US Census lists Henry Mitchel as the head of household living at 21 Rackleff.
I have not found Henry and Margaret in any subsequent records. As such, I have not found the name of the little girl in this photo. I am confident her parents are Harry and Margaret Macdonough, who lived in Portland, Maine, from the 1920s until about 1938.
Philip & Robert McCarthy (Brothers) Circa 1937.
This negative envelope says, “Mrs. Phillip McCarthy, 282 Woodfords St #1101.”
Why I believe this to be the individual.
Philip & Robert McCarthy (Brothers) Circa 1937.
The 1936 Portland city Directory lists Philip C and Alice P McCarthy living at 282 Woodford.
The 1940 US Census lists 41-year-old Philip C McCarthy and his 43-year-old wife Alice living at 276 Woodford. With them are their two sons, Philip J and Robert J. Philip is ten and Robert is seven years old.
Based upon the photo ID Number (#1101), the photo was taken about 1937. Philip would have been about seven and Robert about four. All were born in Maine
Robert J. McCarthy, son of Philip C. McCarthy and Alice P. Gray, was born on 2 May 1932 in Maine. He and his brother Philip are found in four Ancestry Public Trees.
Neither Robert, Philip, nor their parents appear to have profiles on Family Search, so I added their photo to Dead Fred.
Conclusion
I fully identified two of the seven individuals as having Ancestry trees and Family Search profiles, so I uploaded their images to their Family Search Memories.This
I identified four individuals that did not have a Family Search profiles so I posted their images to Dead Fred.
There was one individual I failed to determine their first name. The only image I have of her is hereIf any of these photos are of your family member, I would love to hear your reaction. Especially if this photo is of a loved one for whom you hadn’t seen this photograph before.
Due to software limitations, the images uploaded to Family Search, Dead Fred, and Flickr have a higher image quality than the images linked here.
For all postings of the Ethel Wight Collection, please see here.
Endnotes
[i] The Wight Studio was in Portland, Maine. Many thanks to Ethel Wight’s family for access to and permission to use the collection of their great aunt.
[ii] These images were converted to positives using a lightbox, a Nikon camera and computer software.
I received an email from Ancestry that indicated due to their “proprietary AI technology,” they have an early index of the records. My recollection said it took several months to index the 1940 census ten years ago, and once done, there were a lot of indexing errors. So I wondered if searches of the 1950 census would be effective so soon after its release.
Ancestry included a link 1950 United States Federal Census in their email. I decided to use it and look for my mother and grandmother.
Discovery
The 1950 Census date was April 1st. I was born in Oregon and knew my mom and I flew back to Minnesota in August 1950. So I searched for:
Name: Donna Kees
Any Event Location: Minneapolis, Hennepin, Minnesota.
Bang – Four results. There was a Donna R Kees in Saint Paul, Minnesota. The six-year-old was definitely not my grandmother. However, the second entry returned was Donna M Kees in Detroit[i]. In the same household was Sylvia J Kees. Definitely my grandmother and mother.
Wow! What a treasure trove of information.
Donna and my mom were still in Detroit and lived at 8542 Olivet in April 1950. Donna was only “45 years old.” She was always a bit loose with her age, but saying she was 12 years younger than her actual age was a new record for her. She was an unemployed bakery saleslady and was seeking work.
My mom was an 18-year-old “never married” woman. She too was an unemployed bakery saleslady seeking work.
A little box checked indicated the household was continued on the next page. I turned the page and wow They had a lodger, James K Quigging. He was a 25-year-old divorcee born in Kentucky and working as a metal polisher at an auto factory. Wow. I’ve never heard of him. His living with grandma and my mom is a total surprise.
Even more incredible, Donna was line 29 on the census, which means she was sampled for additional information. I learned that Donna had lived at the same house a year previously. Her education was “S12,” and she had completed her last year of school, so she was a high school graduate. It looks like she had no wages or income in 1949. However, she did have income from others in the household of $450. Donna had been married more than once (I knew that). Line 37 showed she had been divorced for five years. Another surprise. I know that Donna and Russell Kees got together in the late 1930s. It was my understanding they never married, rather just lived together. This entry suggests that she and Russell Kees may have been married and divorced about 1945.
Conclusion
I was impressed. Ancestry’s indexing using their Artificial Intelligence (AI) worked very well. I will definately use it to learn more about my Ancestors.
Using it to learn about my mother and grandmother’s whereabouts in April 1950 brought several new questions.
Who was James K Quigging?
Did Donna and Russell Kees actually get married? Did they get legally divorced?
I understood that Donna went to the Toronto Music Conservatory. I had sensed that it was a college-level type of school. Apparently, it was more of a High School equivalent. I guess I need to learn more about the school.
Endnotes
[i] 1950 Census – Michigan, Wayne, Detroit – ED 85-2022 – Sheet 73 – Line 29 – Donna M Kees, Head, via Ancestry.
Metropolitan Theatre
Vaudeville/Chin-Chin
By Don Taylor
My grandmother was a vaudeville star, and I am following her career, trying to learn about her many performances. In October 1919, she joined the cast of the Charles Dillingham production of “Chin-Chin” “Chin-Chin” played in the US and Canada until June 1920. I monitor several newspaper services watching for new venues that the show played at while she was a cast member.
This week’s entry is from the Minneapolis Journal dated 1 February 1920 via Newspapers.Com
The Minneapolis Journal – Feb 1, 1920 via Newspapers.com
An article on page 3 of the Amusement Section, in a column titled “The Lobby Club,” was an article that read:
“Charles Dillingham’s name still heads the bills as producer of “Chin Chin,” which comes to the Metropolitan this week. Walter Wills and Roy Binder will be seen in the roles created by Montgomery and Stone. This is the only company offering “Chin Chin.” Carrie Dale and Irene McKay are prominent in the cast. The music, as will be remembered, is by Ivan Caryll, while Anne Caldwell wrote the book for the piece.”
New Cast Members Added:
I previously knew about the “Chin Chin” show at the Metropolitan Theatre from 1 to 7 February 1920. This article adds to other individuals who starred in the show, Carrie Dale and Irene McKay. I’ll like to investigate those individuals later.
Roberts Project
Roberts-Barnes-Lister Line
By Don Taylor
After I’ve reviewed and double-checked the Family Search sources, I review the sources other people have cited on Ancestry as the basis for facts they have found. Again, do I agree? Do the sources fit the right person. Are there conflicts that I should address?
William Lister is found in 58 Ancestry public trees. If a tree indicates a spouse for him, the trees suggest Nancy Strain or Leah Adkins. Either spouse is okay, as I believe he was married to both. However, the trees have several different potential parents for William. William & Mary and Nimrod & Mary are most common. Some trees suggest William Nimrod Lister as William’s father. Although interesting to see, I’m interested in the sources others have that might point to those names and provide the basis for other facts.
Looking carefully at the Ancestry sources for William Lister, I found:
1830 Census
William Lister, home in Deerfield, Ross County, Ohio.
I looked at William Lister (1793-1848) in the 1840 Census previously. (See William Lister & the 1830 Census.) I failed to find William in Pickaway County in the 1840 Census and possibly found him in Ross County. I did look carefully at the neighbors near him in the 1830 Census Pickaway County William Lister and looked for them in the 1840 Census. I found seven of the ten closest individuals. Looking at their 1840 neighbors, none of them appear to be a William Lister misspelled or misindexed. I don’t believe the William Lister in Pickaway County in 1830 was enumerated in Pickaway County during the 1840 Census.
Indiana, U.S., Death Certificates, 1899-2011
Death Certificate 22067 – William Marcus Lister
I reviewed this record with the Family Search source citations.
Ohio Marriages, 1800-1958
William Sister [Lister] & Nancy Strain Married on 17 June 1822.
This is the same source I have for their marriage. The link to the record on Ancestry is here.
Ohio Marriages, 1800-1958
William Lister & Lea Adkins Married on 23 April 1846. This is the same record I found earlier. On Ancestry, it is available here.
Indicates William Lister was born in 1793. He enlisted on 30 August 1812 and was discharged on 9 October 1812. His Rank was Private in the Army. He died in 1848 and was buried in New Holland Cemetery, Perry, Pickaway County, Ohio. This record didn’t add any new information or facts for me; however, it does provide a link to the original document on Fold3, which I will download and assess the next time I renew my Fold3 membership.
Find-a-Grave
William Lister’s Marker – Photo by oh_fudge via Find-a-Grave
William Lister’s Find-a-Grave Memorial #38330408[i] includes two photos of his marker. I had this information previously.
The Roll of Capt. Alexander Robinson’s Company (From Ross County) indicated that William Lister served from 30 August until 9 October 1812, and he was from Pickaway county:
….Privates….
Lister, William
War of 1812 Pension Application Files Index, 1812-1815
William Lister
The record provides pension numbers (SC #3871 & SO # 7572) and information that he was also in Capt. Geo Yocums Co. of the Ohio Militia.
Reconciliation
My Records
Ancestry
Birth
1793 Maryland
1793 – Pickaway Co.
Father
Unknown
William, Nimrod, or “William Nimrod”
Mother
Unknown
Mary
Son
James Alfred
I didn’t find any evidence regarding William’s parents in any of the sources. There were references to someone “finding something on the Internet” back in 2000. However, in reading the thread, I didn’t see anything that provided evidence for that finding. Additionally, none of the researchers using Ancestry Public Trees provided a source for William’s parents’ names either.
Conclusion (Part 3)
After reviewing the sources cited on Ancestry:
William’s birth date and location. I’m confident that William Lister was born in 1793 in Maryland. I am not confident regarding his parents’ names.
I still doubt that William had a son James Alfred.
In 1822, William’s wife Nancy would have been 15 years old, suggesting she would have been 14 when James Alfred was conceived.
Alternately, William Lister could have had an earlier wife. I haven’t seen evidence of that in any other records.
It is uncommon for a person to have two children with the same given name.
It is possible but unlikely that William had a wife before Nancy. If I find any evidence of his having has such a wife, I’ll add James Alfred to the mix.
I am convinced that William Marcus Lister was born on 2 August 1832 in Pickaway County, Ohio.
I feel comfortable writing a sketch regarding William Lister’s life with the additional research I’ve done.
Endnotes
[i] Find a Grave, Find a Grave, William Lister, Pvt – 1793-1848. Find a Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/38330408/william-lister: accessed 17 February 2022), memorial page for Pvt William Lister (1793–20 Nov 1848), Find a Grave Memorial ID 38330408, citing New Holland Cemetery, New Holland, Pickaway County, Ohio, USA ; Maintained by Dave M (contributor 46499754).
This week, for Photo Friday, I identify the people in five more envelopes from the Ethel Wight Studio Collection
