Tax Records – James Howell of Buckingham County, Virginia

By Don Taylor
Howell Research

In his book, The Life and Travels of Peter M. Howell, Peter M. Howell names Gideon Howell as his brother. Gideon’s 1872 death record gives his parents as James and Nancy Howell. My earlier research showed that James, Peter’s father, moved to Buckingham County, Virginia, about 1807 and died about 1817–1818.

Tracing James in Buckingham County is hard. The county courthouse burned in 1869, and the deeds, wills, and marriage records made before then were lost with it. Those are the records a genealogist normally checks first. The county’s personal property tax records did survive, so I used them to learn what I could about James, Gideon, and the other Howells living in Buckingham County during James’s lifetime.

A note on spelling: The Buckingham County tax records spell the surname “Howel,” while most other records I’ve found use “Howell.” I use “Howel” when talking about the tax records.

What the Tax Records Say About James

James Howel appears on the 1815 tax list. By 1817, the taxes were being paid by the Estate of James Howel. The 1817 entry lists one tithable, meaning one white male of taxable age, living on the property. James had died by then, so this was someone else in the household. Who he was is still an open question.

Because his estate paid the 1817 tax, James had probably died before the 1817 list was made. That would put his death between 1815 and early 1817.

Two Gideon Howels

Two other Howels appear alongside James: Gideon and Pleasant. At first I assumed this Gideon was Peter’s brother. But Peter’s brother was born about 1808, so he was far too young to be on the 1815 tax list. This was a different, older Gideon.

The elder Gideon. He paid taxes every year from 1811 through 1820 (no 1816 entry is recorded). His estate paid them in 1821, 1822, and 1823. That means he died between March 1820 and May 1821. The 1810 census lists a Gideon Howell in Buckingham County who was over 45, with a wife, one son, and one daughter. I’m fairly confident this is the Gideon who died in 1820–1821.

In 1824, a new name appears on the tax lists: Salley Howel. I believe she was the elder Gideon’s widow. For now, I’ve recorded his wife’s name as Sally.

The younger Gideon. Gideon C. Howel first appears in 1824 and again in 1826. If he was born about 1808, he would have been about 16 in 1824. That is about the age young men first appear on Virginia tax lists, so it fits Peter’s brother well.

Summary of Howels in the Buckingham County Tax Records

  • Gideon Howel – 1811, 1812, 1813, 1814, 1815, 1817, 1818, 1819, 1820
  • Estate of Gideon Howel – 1821, 1822, 1823
  • Gideon C. Howel – 1824, 1826
  • Isaac Howel & Son – 1813
  • James Howel – 1815
  • Estate of James Howel – 1817
  • Pleasant Howel – 1811, 1813, 1817
  • Salley Howel (probably the elder Gideon’s widow) – 1824, 1826
  • Stephen Howel – 1812

Conclusion and Next Steps

The tax records can’t replace the lost wills and deeds, but they tell me a lot. They place James in Buckingham County by 1815 and show he had died by 1817. They separate two men named Gideon: an elder Gideon who died in 1820–1821, probably leaving a widow named Sally, and Gideon C., who first appears in 1824 at about the age Peter’s brother would have been. They also show other Howels in the county, including Pleasant, Isaac and his son, and Stephen. They may have been related to James, but I don’t yet know how.

What the tax lists can’t do is show how these people were related. My next step is to look closely at the surviving census records:

  • 1810: Look at the elder Gideon’s household again, and look for James, who should have been in the county by then.
  • 1820: James had died by this time, so I’ll look for Nancy Howell as head of household. I’ll check whether the ages of her children fit Peter and Gideon C.
  • 1830 and 1840: Follow Sally, Gideon C., Pleasant, and any other Howells.
  • 1850: This is the first census that names every member of a household. It should finally let me compare names, ages, and birthplaces with what the tax records suggest.

Together, the tax and census records should give a clearer picture of James and Nancy Howell’s family in Buckingham County.


Discover more from Don Taylor Genealogy

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

This entry was posted in Howell-Hobbs, Research & Methodology and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.